Nuclear radiation killing more female than male embryos

Radiation from German nuclear dumps is killing more female than male human embryos, a scientific researcher reports.

Ralf Kusmierz, one of several authors of a study for the Helmholtz Zentrum München, a government state research institution, says they have found “significantly fewer” girls than boys being born in the vicinity of Gorleben, where nuclear waste is stored in a light-construction hall, and near the flooding underground Asse dump near Salzgitter.

“The gender relationship at birth is naturally determined,” Kusmierz explained on a television programme, “there are slightly more boys than girls.”

“In Lüchow-Dannenberg County [Gorleben] up to 1995 the relationship was 102 boys to 100 girls, slightly under the national average. Since 1996 the relationship [male majority] has been rising constantly.

“It is worrying because we have found an increased relationship in the vicinity of nuclear power stations. That is highly likely to be due to radioactive emissions.”
Kusmierz noted that the male majority of births also leaped up after the 1986 Chernobyl disaster, in direct proportion to the radioactive contamination.

“The closer one is to Ukraine, the bigger the increase.”

Hence it was highly likely that radiation kills more female embryos and that more boys are born alive. “So it’s not a case of more boys, but fewer girls.”

Kusmierz doesn’t think it’s a coincidence and puts the likelihood of mistakes in the study at under five percent.

Already last year he found that in the community of Remlingen surrounding the Asse dump,the most contaminated legacy of Germany’s nuclear power industry, the proportion of boys among births was also extremely skewed.

Because emissions of radioactive gases are known there, the cause was recognisable, he argues. But in Gorleben he had no clear indications.

“It’s mysterious. I inquired at the environment ministry in Hanover [responsible for Gorleben] and was told, ‘There are no emissions from these [CASTOR] containers.’ So it means, we actually know no cause.”

Kusmierz demands that legislators investigate the phenomenon further.

The Lower Saxony state government says it does not rule out further radiation measurements. A spokeswoman said radiation could lead to fewer girls being born. But she could say no more yet about the study because only excerpts were available so far.

“The numbers are extremely worrying,” said the environment spokesman of The Left group in the Lower Saxony parliament, Kurt Herzog. The right-of-centre government needed to act speedi;y.

“I demand that the smallscale monitoring be started immediately that social minister Aygül Özkan announced because of the cancer cases in the Asse.“

It became known recently that in the vicinity of Asse double the number of leukemia cases and triple the number of thyroind cancers as the national average were discovered. A working group is trying to find out the reasons for the increased cancer rate.

Comments

Maybe just be a coincidence, but that could be the cellphone towers as well.

(Or all of the above.)

Stuck in the middle of changing "May just be a" into "Maybe just a".

So sorry - cannot hide the fact of being tortured with electronic surveillance in my home and with covert stalking in public.

why not link to your sources, or at least name them. "a television programme" is a bit hard for me to look up.

Sir,

there is no evidence for nuclear radiation causing the sexodds chance in the vicinity of Gorleben. But of course there is a strong effect.

Now the complete data for this case. The investigation area is shown here: http://img26.imageshack.us/img26/3259/umgebunggorleben.png

It is divided into three zones:

Zone A (Inner zone - red)
Municipalities: Gorleben, Höhbeck, and Trebel

Zone B (Middle zone - orange)
Municipalities: Damnatz, Gartow, Gusborn, Langendorf, Lemgow, Lübbow, Lüchow, Prezelle, Schnackenburg, and Woltersdorf

Zone C (Outer zone - blue)
Municipalities: Bergen, Clenze, Dannenberg, Göhrde, Hitzacker, Jameln, Karwitz, Küsten, Luckau, Nahrendorf, Neu Darchau, Rosche, Schnega, Stoetze, Suhlendorf, Tosterglope, Waddeweitz, Wustrow, and Zernien

(Non-municipality areas ("gemeindefreie Gebiete") Göhrde and Gartow are coloured grey. Amt Neuhaus belongs to Lower Saxony ("Niedersachsen") only since 1993 and was not included.)

Within the three zones were count following live births:

_______________________1971-1995
_______________________________95-%-Confidence-
_______________m____f____m/f___intervall_of_m/f
_____Zone_A:__266__294_0.9048___0.7636_1.0716
_____Zone_B:_2190_2138_1.0243___0.9646_1.0877
_____Zone_C:_4501_4411_1.0204___0.9787_1.0639
Zones_A+B+C:_6957_6843_1.0167___0.9832_1.0513

_______________________1996-2009
_______________________________95-%-Confidence-
_______________m____f____m/f___intervall_of_m/f
_____Zone_A:__120__111_1.0811___0.8281_1.4123
_____Zone_B:_1091__967_1.1282___1.0337_1.2315
_____Zone_C:_2260_2104_1.0741___1.0118_1.1404
Zones_A+B+C:_3471_3182_1.0908___1.0393_1.1449

This results in following sex odds ratios of births compared after 1995 and until 1995:

_____Zone_A:_1.1949;_p-value_=_0.2554
_____Zone_B:_1.1014;_p-value_=_0.0716
_____Zone_C:_1.0527;_p-value_=_0.1650
-------------------------------------
__Zones_A+B:_1.1124;_p-value_=_0.0357
Zones_A+B+C:_1.0729;_p-value_=_0.0184

All zones show increasing sex odds against the general decreasing trend after 1995, stronger within lower distance from the CASTOR store. Within single zones, increase is not significant due to small births numbers (p-values 0.2554; 0.0716, and 0.1650 - zone B is borderline-significant).

But the increase of 11.24 % within the combined zones A and B is significant on the 95-%-level with a p-value of 0.0357, and all zones A, B and C combined show a very significanten increase of 7.29 % with a p-value of 0.0184.

See also: http://www.helmholtz-muenchen.de/ibb/homepage/hagen.scherb/proceedings.html

Kind regards,
R. Kusmierz